Tomy Electric Breast Pump Review (2019 Edition) - It's Affordable, But Is It Good?

Photo by @mmoro_photo

We know that feeling. You want to breastfeed your baby. But, at this point in your life, a McDonald’s value meal seems like a big purchase. What options do you have for a breastfeeding pump that won’t put you further into debt?

Our Tomy The First Years Quiet Expressions breast pump review will shine a light on one of the most affordable double electric breast pumps out there.

In This Guide

    Product Overview

    The first thing you’re going to notice about The First Years Quiet Expressions pump is the price. You’ll likely do a double take when you look at the cost, thinking you read the amount wrong. You didn’t – it really is a great deal for a double electric breast pump.

    It comes with a surprising number of extras for the money too. You’ll get:

    • The pump unit
    • One tote bag to hold all the pumping equipment
    • Two 4-ounce GumDrop bottles with storage lids and slow-flow nipples
    • The ac adapter
    PROS:
    • Price – you probably won’t find a more inexpensive double electric breast pump.
    • The included tote bag is stylish and holds everything without being too bulky.
    CONS:
    • There isn’t a backlit display, which would be nice for pumping sessions in the wee hours of the night.
    • Doesn’t express milk as quickly as other pumps.
    • The pump motor doesn’t last as long as other pumps.

    Key Features and Benefits

    The included tote bag doesn’t scream breast pump as soon as you see it:

    For moms who are into discretion, breast pump totes can be a double-edged sword. They are nice to have because they conveniently hold everything you need, but many people, especially other moms, know you are carting around a breast pump in there. You aren’t fooling anyone.

    You love being a mom, but that doesn’t mean you want to look like a mom all the time.

    This bag has a little more flair to it than some other breast pump tote bags do, which may appeal to moms who are fashion conscious.

    The Flexi-fit breast shields are soft and designed to provide an ideal fit for moms of all sizes:

    Breast shields can make or break a pump. It doesn’t matter how much milk is pumped out, if a breast shield is painful or overly uncomfortable, moms aren’t going to use or recommend that pump to their friends.

    Women spend a lot of time pumping and there are many options out there, so there’s no reason to feel like you’re being tortured at Guantanamo Bay just to provide your baby with some breastmilk. These breast shields help make pumping more tolerable.

    The First Years pump offers eight adjustable suction settings:

    This pump doesn’t employ a one-size-fits-all strategy. You are able to play around with the suction settings, which can help you stick with breastfeeding when the going gets tough and your nipples begin to feel like you’re using sandpaper on them.

    You can either plug this unit into an outlet or use 4 AA batteries to make it run:

    That really adds to this pump’s versatility. Some pumps only offer one or the other – battery power or a power cord. Having both provides women with a lot of freedom. They can pump in the car on long trips when their partner is driving or they can plug it in when battery power isn’t needed.

    The handle lets you operate the pump with just one hand, even when you’re pumping both breasts:

    A long handle that runs vertically between your breasts is what allows you to pump only using one hand. That’s a perk for moms who want to be able to multitask while pumping. You can cyber surf, make phone calls or catch up on some reading while you are pumping.

    This pump is light enough to take with you on the go:

    At just over 3 pounds, you can pile these pump pieces into the included tote bag and barely notice the extra weight as you head to your car.


    How Does It Compare?

    1. Philips AVENT

    Moms who find the vertical handle on the Tomy pump uncomfortable to hold for long pumping sessions may want to check out the Philips AVENT double electric comfort breast pump. The wide base of the collection bottles lets moms comfortably hold on to them while pumping, eliminating hand cramps.

    2. Spectra S1

    Moms who like the added safety of a closed system may want to read up on the Spectra S1, which is a hospital-grade pump that can help guard the safety of the breastmilk you’ll serve your baby by reducing contamination.

    3. NUK Expressive Double

    Moms who don’t want to use an extra tote to carry breast pumping supplies may like the NUK Expressive pump, which is a fairly small double electric breast pump that could fit in a plastic bag in a big purse. The pump only weighs one pound.

    4. Medela Pump In Style

    Moms who don’t have any spare minutes in their day for relaxation may want to consider the Pump In Style, which can express milk faster than many other pumps on the market.

    5. Freemie Freedom

    Moms who think that even using one hand for pumping is too much work will want to check out the Freemie Freedom double electric pump. It’s a hands-free pump that allows you to wear your shirt while pumping, thanks to its concealable collection cups.


    Who Should Buy This Pump?

    Some moms aren’t flush with cash. In a perfect world, moms would have all the resources they need to breastfeed, but that isn’t a reality yet for our society.

    If you don’t have medical insurance to cover the cost of a new pump, you will probably need to find a pump that adequately meets your needs for a price you can afford.

    The First Years Quiet Expressions pump accomplishes that goal, and it makes breastfeeding more accessible for women who don’t have as much disposable income.

    33 Steps To Pumping Success: How To Pump More Milk
    33 Steps To Pumping Success: How To Pump More Milk
    How to Tell If Your Breast Milk Has Gone Bad
    How to Tell If Your Breast Milk Has Gone Bad
    Pump or Sleep? Do I Need to Pump at Night to Maintain Supply?
    Pump or Sleep? Do I Need to Pump at Night to Maintain Supply?
    13 Best Breast Pumps on the Market (2019 Reviews)
    13 Best Breast Pumps on the Market (2019 Reviews)
    How to Wean When You’re Exclusively Pumping In 7 Steps
    How to Wean When You’re Exclusively Pumping In 7 Steps
    Spectra S2 vs Medela Pump In Style (2019 Comparison Guide)
    Spectra S2 vs Medela Pump In Style (2019 Comparison Guide)

    4 Reader Comments

    1. Can you pump without the handle attached?

      • Jenny Silverstone

        Yes, I believe you can! (source)

    2. Jamie J Garcia

      I absolutely love this pump (actually more so than the Ameda pump my insurance company sent me)! I love that it doesn’t have various complicated parts, it’s super easy to use on the go and the company is seriously amazing! I went to my in-laws over the weekend and forgot my pump hose….?! I wanted to cry! I searched every website to find/order a replacement hose and after no luck, I reached out to the manufacturer and they rush mailed me a replacement hose at no charge! I love that the flanges are rubberized so it sticks better and I have more movement but I also love that the suction control is a button and not knobs, which will come in extremely handy when I am commute pumping, lol. The tote is super cute and not bulky or too big. I actually have room for my wallet and cell phone as well. I definitely recommend this affordable pump!

      • Team Mom Loves Best

        Hey Jamie, what a great review you’ve written! Thanks so much for commenting and for reading Mom Loves Best. We appreciate your contributions. How are you finding pumping as a whole though? Any challenges?

    Leave a Comment