Medela Pump In Style Advanced Reviews (2020 Edition)

Is the Medela PIS the right pump for you?

Some breast pumps look good on paper, but when you use them you find problems – the suction isn’t as powerful as you had hoped or you have no way of packing away all the pump pieces together. Before you’ve finished the first pumping session, you’re wishing you had ordered another pump instead.

This Medela Pump In Style Review will help you get a clear picture of what this breast pump can and can’t do so there won’t be any surprises when you go to use it.

Product Overview

Medela Pump in Style Advanced with On the Go Tote, Double Electric Breast Pump,...
Shop This Product

The Medela Pump In Style has the ability to make long pumping sessions a thing of the past. No mom wants to spend 30 minutes out of her day attached to an inconvenient breast pump.

The Pump In Style can express your precious breast milk in just a few minutes each session, which is a great time saver for pumping moms.

This kit comes with everything you’ll need including:

  • One microfiber bag
  • Four 5oz breast milk bottles & lids
  • One cooler bag and ice pack
  • One double pumping kit with 24mm breast shields
  • One 9-Volt AC adapter
  • One battery pack
  • This breast pump is made to be used multiple times a day.
  • Cleaning it is easy.
  • Quickly expresses milk.
  • Can be used with a car adapter.
  • It is expensive compared to other breast pumps.
  • It is heavier than many other breast pumps.

Key Features and Benefits

  • The pump is fastened into the inside of the bag with Velcro strips, but it can easily be removed if you want to use the pump outside of the bag.
  • It has a two-phase expression technology that includes a one-touch let-down button.
    This feature is supposed to be like a real baby when it is feeding. The pump will begin a pumping session with a fast, lighter pull on your nipple that is supposed to signal that your milk needs to begin flowing. After that, the pump begins with the full on pumping that will remove your milk.
  • The pump kit comes with several accessories.
    For instance, it comes with a cooler bag and ice packs, as well as four bottles.
    The cooler bag and ice packs make it easy to keep the milk cool until it is properly stored. This is a nice feature for moms who pump during their lunch breaks at work. They can be assured their hard work won’t go to waste since they’ll be able to safely and discreetly store the milk until they get home.
  • This pump is portable.
    Unless you remove it from its compartment in its carrying bag, it will be ready to grab and go whenever you have to head out the door.
  • If you plan on almost exclusively pumping, this pump will be able to handle that kind of repeated action.
    Some pumps are better suited to a lighter pumping schedule, but if you plan for your baby to take most of her breast milk from bottles rather than straight from the breast, this pump should be able to do the job with ease.

Build Quality

  • This pump’s motor definitely does the job, but it is one of the louder ones on the market.
    If you are at home when you are pumping, that might not bother you. If you are at a friend’s house or at work, the noise might be annoying.

Ease of Use

  • At 8 and a half pounds, this kit might weigh more than your newborn baby did.
    While the weight of this unit might not bother you if you are just going from room to room in your house, it can become a real issue carting it around for longer stretches of time outside the house.
    If you take your breast pump with you a lot outside of the house, you’ll may want to consider a lighter option.
  • You won’t be scratching your head, trying to solve the riddle of how to operate this pump.
    It’s easy to understand, which is good news for moms who aren’t mechanically inclined. As a mom, I know there’s nothing worse than trying to figure out how new products work when you’re already worried about how you’ll manage to get everything done.
  • Moisture and condensation can build up in this tubing easily, unless you run the pump for a few minutes after you’ve finished pumping your milk.
    While moms don’t need one more hoop to jump through simply to breastfeed their babies, you have to take this step to protect your baby from contaminated milk at your next pumping session.
  • You can pump both breasts at once with the Medela pump or you can do one breast at a time.
    This machine makes pumping both breasts at once an easy process, unlike some other pumps which make it difficult to do with only two hands.
  • Moms should be careful when they set the collection bottles down after they have been filled.
    The lightweight material of these bottles makes them easy to tip over and spill.

How Do They Compare?

Spectra S2

Moms who don’t want to bulk up just from lifting their breast pump may want to go for the much lighter Spectra S2, which weighs 3.3 pounds – around 5 pounds lighter than the Pump In Style.

The First Years Quiet Expressions

Moms who want to have a double electric breast pump, but plan to do more nursing than pumping may want to cut corners on the cost by getting The First Years Quiet Expressions, a much cheaper breast pump.

NUK Expressive Double

Moms who are looking for a breast pump they can assemble in no time may want to consider the NUK Expressive, which has only a few easy-to-connect parts.

Medela Freestyle

The Freestyle might be a good choice for busy women who don’t mind paying extra money for a hands-free pump. If they are strapped for time, the extra money might be well spent on a pump like this that allows them to multitask while expressing.

Ameda Purely Yours

Moms who are concerned with the possibility of their milk being contaminated by an open system may want to consider the Ameda Purely Yours pump, which is a closed system. The milk never touches the tubing of the Purely Yours Pump.

Who Should Buy This Pump?

The Pump In Style should appeal to moms who want to quickly express their breast milk so they don’t feel like they’ve spent the better part of their day hooked up to a pump.

It will also appeal to moms who like the idea of having one tote that will hold their pump and all the breast pump accessories they need.

Things to Know Before You Buy

You’re going to be parting with your hard-earned money to buy a device that you know will make you uncomfortable. If you are going to be breastfeeding instead of giving your baby formula, you’ll need a pump for when you can’t be with your baby but you still want your baby to have the health benefits of drinking breast milk. Pumping ahead of time will let you have milk in the refrigerator or freezer so your baby’s nutritional needs will be covered.

Pumping breast milk isn’t fun, but it’s a necessary evil. You need to give your baby the best start you can, and breast milk will do that. And while pumping will never be your idea of a good time, there are breast pump features that can make the experience more tolerable (1).

Here are some tips to help you choose the right breast pump:

  • Don’t be tempted by the cheap pumps on the market. They’re inexpensive for a reason – they don’t do the job well, they can be loud and can hurt your already sore nipples.
  • See if the brand offers a variety of breast shield sizes for different fits. When you’re looking for your correct size and fit, keep in mind the fit isn’t about the size of your breast – it’s about the size of your nipple. Your nipple will be pulled into the shield’s opening, which is why a precise fit with the correct size of breast shields matters so much.
  • Don’t use a previously owned pump. You should purchase your own because there are health issues with using someone else’s pump (2).
  • Decide if you will need a pump for occasional use or everyday use. Breast pumps can either be electric or battery powered or hand operated.
Headshot of jenny_silverstone

Edited by

Jenny Silverstone

Jenny Silverstone is a professional writer, editor, and most importantly, the loving mother of two. Jenny's goal at Mom Loves Best is to help the other moms like her who are struggling and trying to do their best but feel totally overwhelmed.
Has Your Breast Milk Gone Bad? (3 Things You Can Check)How to Tell if Your Breast Milk’s Gone Bad
Pump or Sleep? Do I Need to Pump at Night to Maintain Supply?Should You Pump At Night to Maintain Supply?
How To Pump More Breast Milk (33 Steps To Pumping Success)How To Pump More Milk: The Ultimate Guide
How to Stop Breast Pumping (7 Simple Steps)How to Wean off Pumping (7 Steps to Follow)
Best Breast Pumps of 202015 Best Breast Pumps for YOU (2020 Reviews)
Spectra S2 vs Medela Pump In StyleSpectra S2 vs Medela Pump In Style