Pull up diapers are said to be one of the best tools to use when potty training, but are they truly effective? Which kind should you get?
Potty training is an important milestone for your child, but it can be a long and frustrating process. If anything can help, it’s no wonder you’d want to learn more about it.
We’ve gathered everything you need to know about the best pull up diapers, potty training, and a whole lot more. Together, we’ll take a closer look at how you can use them to help your child gain more control over their bodies while providing you peace of mind.
Quick ComparisonOur Top Pull Up Diaper Picks of 2020 Read Full Reviews
Pull Ups & Potty Training 101
Before we take a look at why pull up diapers are beneficial for potty training, let’s consider some potty training basics.
1. What is potty training?
Potty training is the process of teaching a child to control their bladder and use a toilet when they have to go. This includes understanding and recognizing the body’s signals for needing to use the bathroom, how to use the toilet safely, and how to remove their clothing (source). As adults, we find this process very simple, but it can be a lot for a child to master.
2. When do I start potty training?
However, every child is different, so don’t be alarmed if your child seems early or takes a bit longer.
The best way to potty train is by making it a positive experience for your child. Forcing them into the process is a sure way to make everyone involved stressed and upset.
3. How do pull ups help?
There are many different types of pull up diapers and training pants available, but all of them are designed to transition your child from a diaper to regular underwear. This is achieved by creating a diaper underwear hybrid.
Training pants generally look and function more like underwear, the most distinctive feature being that your child can pull them on and off. But they’re still made of absorbent diaper materials so accidents aren’t a big deal.
4. How many pull ups do I need?
Honestly, there is no way to provide an exact number. It all comes down to your child’s readiness and unique biology. Some super young children potty train early and can be out of pull ups in no time, while other older children struggle with bedwetting for years.
We suggest purchasing a regular pack of pull ups and seeing how many you go through each day. This should help you gauge how many you need. Remember, the goal is to use as few as possible because that means your child isn’t having accidents.
Pull Ups vs. Training Pants
If you think it’s time to start your child’s potty training journey, you may be surprised to discover the vast number of options you have when it comes to training pants. Let’s take a close look at each one and how they differ from each other.
What are pull ups?
Pull ups are the most common and recognizable form of potty training underwear. Multiple brands carry them in a variety of styles and types. But what exactly are they?
There are always some differences across brands, but pull ups are generally the most diaper-like of the bunch. The material is thinner than a diaper but designed to be super absorbent, holding in both urine and feces.
The big difference is how the pull up is worn. Instead of using adhesive panels to open a diaper, a pull up slips up and down like regular underwear.
If you’re just beginning with potty training or are still having a lot of accidents, pull ups are a great option to avoid big messes.
What are training pants?
As a term, “training pants” can be a bit confusing. Most brands will use the term at some point, whether they’re referring to a pull up, an underwear cover, or even more absorbent underwear.
However, training pants are a specific kind of potty training underwear. Think of it like this: pull ups are closer to diapers than underwear, while training pants are closer to underwear than diapers.
Most are designed to be worn alone and are not made of the plastic, absorbent fabrics you find in diapers. They’re still absorbent, sometimes being made of thicker cloth or with heavier layers in the crotch.
Training pants are most useful for children who are further along in their potty training. They can help with smaller accidents but are not meant for bigger blowouts.
What are underwear covers?
They’ve gone out of fashion, but a third option is an underwear cover. Often made of a thin, waterproof plastic, these covers can be worn over any other type of potty training underwear to prevent leaks and messes.
If you use cloth diapers or training pants, they can be especially good at protecting your child and anything they come in contact with while potty training.
Finding the Best Pull Ups
If you’ve ever been in the baby or toddler section of any supermarket, you’ve seen pull ups. In fact, you’ve probably seen so many you may not know how to choose. From finding a brand you can trust to getting the sizing just right, you’ve got a lot of options.
Here are five helpful tips to help you make the choice.
- Absorbency: Nothing is more distressing than having a major blow-out. Pull ups are meant to instill confidence, so super absorbent material is important, helping you and your child feel more secure.
- Stretchy Waistband: One of the goals of potty training is to help your child learn how to take underwear on and off. A secure, but stretchy waistband is essential. They’ll be able to hook their little fingers into the waistband and pull it down or up.
- Tear-away Sides: As important as it is for your child to be able to put on pull ups themselves, pretty big accidents can happen. In emergencies, you’ll want a pull up diaper with tear-away sides so a parent can remove it quickly if needed.
- Easy Sizing Information: Sizing varies by brand, but any good pull up will have easy-to-understand sizing information right on the packaging. We suggest trying out smaller packs of pull ups to ensure the size fits correctly before buying in bulk.
- Fun Designs: Children will be more excited about potty training if they’re excited about their pull ups. Look for a brand with recognizable characters or designs your child will enjoy. We even think you should take them to the store and let them pick out their favorite set themselves.
Do You Really Need Pull Ups?
Technically, pull up diapers aren’t required for potty training. You don’t need anything for potty training if you’re willing to work with your child through any potential accidents with regular underwear.
However, we definitely suggest using some sort of training pants, especially if you and your child often go out.
The Best Pull Up Diaper Reviews of 2020
Potty training isn’t just new and scary for your little one — it can be hard on you, too! But the right pull ups can take some of the stress out of the transition. We’ve done some research and found some truly awesome options for moms with all sorts of needs.
1. GoodNites Bedtime Bedwetting Underwear
Some of the biggest accidents occur at night. Your child’s body is not attuned to waking up when the body needs to relieve itself. When looking for a good overnight diaper, keep an eye out for super absorbent materials with a good fit. You don’t want the pull up coming off while your child moves in their bed.
This is the number one nighttime protection brand for pull ups, offering up 40 percent more protection than other leading brands. No matter your child’s size or frame, super stretchy sides, and double leg barriers ensure a superior fit.
They’re made of super absorbent materials and come with five layers of protection. It’s also odor absorbing, so your child can remain discreet if a bedwetting accident happens at sleepover or campout.
One reason we like this line is the specialized design for boys and girls, so each gets leak protection where they need it the most. You can then find everything sorted by the appropriate size, which comes in a large range.
If you’re a mom to a child who struggles with bedwetting for any reason, these are especially good at rebuilding their confidence and avoiding embarrassing situations.
- Offers 40 percent more protection than other leading brands.
- Comes in specific male and female designs so your child gets focused protection.
- Absorbs odor for discretion.
- These do not have tear-away sides, so it’l be harder for parents to get off of younger children if they have an accident.
2. Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants
Potty training takes a lot of patience…and a lot of pull-ups. Whether you’ve got a lot of accidents or your child is having a hard time transitioning from diapers, many moms need more pull ups than they realize. Save yourself time and money by purchasing in bulk.
This set from Pampers includes an entire month’s supply of pull ups. That’s 140 in each box. You’ll be able to go through as many as you need without stressing or making another trip to the store.
Plus, they’ve got some great potty training features to help your child. The easy absorb channels whisk away moisture and provide outstanding protection against leaks. Dual leak guards around your baby’s legs also prevent accidents.
Overall, we like these pull-ups for moms looking to remove stress from their lives while also providing their child with all the help they need to make the transition to big kid underwear.
- Month supply saves you time and money.
- Easy absorb channels and leak guards prevent accidents from turning into huge messes.
- Super fun designs are available for boys and girls.
- They fit small on more robust toddlers.
3. Pull Ups Cool & Learn for Boys
Designing a pull up for boys isn’t just about superheroes and the color blue. Male genitalia require some extra protection in certain areas: look for pull ups with absorbent layers right in the front and down through the bottom.
With numerous “me-do” features, these will not only foster independence, but encourage your little one to continue on their potty training adventure.
Each pull up is absorbent and can be worn day and night. Most importantly, it has an extra absorbent panel that extends up the front specifically for your boy’s needs. The super comfy fit also allows for lots of movement so your child can climb, roll, and explore without fear.
One of the nicest features is the cooling effect. When the pull up gets wet, your child will experience a brief cooling sensation that lets them know they’ve urinated before the liquid is absorbed. This can help your child understand when they need to go to the bathroom.
Other features include tear-away sides and exclusive Disney designs your child will be excited to wear.
Just as important as being able to tear these away, certain brands tear away too easily. My kiddos have removed some of these WAY TOO easily. Overall a huge fan of the Pull Ups Cool & Learn.
Editor's Note:Emily Watts
- Extra absorbent in the front, where boys need it.
- The cooling feature helps your child understand when they’ve urinated.
- Super stretchy fit allows for movement for active boys.
- While they can be worn at night, they’re not absorbent enough to handle major leaking or blowouts.
4. Pull Ups Cool & Learn for Girls
Because they don’t need as much protection in the front, girls can wear any pull up they want and you can still have peace of mind. However, little girls love to be inspired to do great things and many pull ups feature their favorite fictional role models. When looking for pull ups for girls, let them be involved in finding one they love and will be inspired by.
These ones from Cool and Learn help girls feel in control during potty training. A brief cooling sensation signals they’ve gone to the bathroom, teaching them about how their body works.
Parents will love the easy-open sides in case of accidents and the super absorbent materials that provide protection both day and night. However, they still look and feel like underwear so your child can be excited about potty training.
Best of all, your little girl will love seeing some of her favorite inspiring characters on each pull up. When a girl gets excited and sets her mind to something, she’ll succeed! These pull ups will definitely help girls succeed in potty training.
- Cute and fun designs girls will love and be inspired by.
- The cooling feature gives feedback and helps your little girl understand her body better.
- Easy to pull on and off.
- While they can be worn at night, they’re not up to the task of containing major blowouts.
5. Bambo Nature Training Pants
If your child has sensitive skin or if you’re committed to being eco-friendly, a natural pull up is the way to go. You’ll feel good every time about having your child wear them. The key to finding a good natural pull up is to get one that’s both free of harsh chemicals and made of more organic materials.
These are perfect for preventing irritation and rashes. Each one has been manufactured from fabric pulp taken from sustainable forests, which means more trees are planted than cut down. Plus, we love that they’ve been dermatologically tested for sensitive skin.
The soft material is super breathable and flexible, so it’ll fit around the curve of your child’s legs with ease. We also like that it comes with a special strip of tape down the back. When you’re ready to dispose of the pull-up, just tear away the sides, roll it up, and use the tape to secure it in a bundle.
Overall, the standards these pull ups meet is impressive. They’re even approved by the Nordic Ecolabel, which has rigorous demands for products in terms of the environment and your health.
- Made from eco-friendly materials that won’t irritate your child’s sensitive skin.
- Special disposable tape makes clean up a breeze.
- Meets high-quality standards for the environment and your health.
- More expensive, so it may not be great for moms on a budget.
6. Huggies Little Movers Slip On Diaper Pants
Is your baby just learning to walk? Let these pull ups help them gain confidence in movement without discomfort. They’ve been designed just with your little move in mind.
Each features a stretchy waistband and easy remove tabs. Your baby will be able to pull it on and off without any trouble, but you’ll also be able to react quickly if a major accident occurs.
The material feels like underwear on the outside, but like a diaper on the inside. This helps your baby transition because it’ll feel more familiar and soft against their skin.
Plus, the absorbent material whisks away moisture quickly and moves with your child. They’ll be able to move around freely as they learn to walk and you’ll love the 12-hour leakproof protection. We also really like the trim, slimmer fit for extra mobility and flexibility.
If you’ve got a baby who loves to walk, this pull up is for you.
- Trim, slim fit offers a greater range of motion for little movers.
- Feels like underwear on the outside, but a diaper on the inside.
- Features a stretchy waistband and easy remove tabs.
- Some moms have noticed rashes after use.
7. Seventh Generation Toddler Potty Training Pants
Whether your child is ready to go through potty training at a younger age or they’re just a bit small for their age, finding pull ups that fit properly is essential. If they don’t fit, then both you and your child can experience a lot of stress, frustration, and embarrassment when accidents happen.
Even though these pull ups are labeled as mediums, don’t let that fool you. They’re the smallest size available in pull ups, with the next step down being actual diapers. These were specifically designed to fit children up to 35 pounds, making it the perfect choice for children just turning two but who are eager to potty train.
These are also natural, which is great for younger children who may still be experiencing skin sensitivity. Each is made from totally chlorine-free processed wood pulp and is also free of lotions and fragrances.
The designs were made to fit and delight both girls and boys. Your child can take them on and off like regular underwear, but there are also tear-away sides if major accidents occur and you need to step in.
- Come in the smallest size available in pull ups.
- Natural materials and lack of chemicals are great for smaller, younger children with sensitive skin.
- Super absorbent core makes the beginning stages of potty training easier.
- The small sizing is designed to fit a wide range, so if your child is on the super small end, these may still be too big.
8. Babyfriend Reusable Toilet Training Pants
While you’ve got to get used to laundering any major blowouts, cloth pull ups are actually great for potty training because you won’t go through them like diapers and they can be used over and over again. Look for something thinner than a diaper so your child can feel the difference and become accustomed to traditional underwear.
These special training pants are made of 100 percent cotton and have four absorbent layers. They also have a waterproof lining to make small accidents less of a problem. Each pack comes with five different designs and a variety of sizing options are available.
We really like that these cloth pull ups are so comfortable. They’re durable and washable but feel soft and gentle on your child’s bottom. Pull ups with waterproof linings are normally very crinkly and uncomfortable, but these won’t scratch or itch your child at all.
Because they’re thinner than most pull ups, we suggest using these for children who are almost done potty training but may need a little bit of support. They’re the pull ups most similar to regular underwear and great for that final transition.
It’s important to note that while the waterproof lining helps protect against accidental drips, any heavy flow will cause these to leak and can soak through to clothes. If your child is still having pretty major accidents, you may want to wait before trying these.
- Durable and washable, so you can use them over and over again.
- Thin and soft like regular underwear.
- Waterproof lining is comfortable.
- Won’t protect against major leaks or accidents.
9. Dappi Waterproof Diaper Pants
After burning through so many diapers, you may be ready to ditch any sort of disposable, absorbent underwear that crosses your path. This is especially true of moms on a budget. In my opinion, the best way to stay on budget is to only use your favorite pull ups when they’re absolutely necessary and you can’t afford a major blowout. For the rest of the time, use an underwear cover instead.
These super affordable underwear covers combine quality and affordability. Made of durable, waterproof nylon, they slip right over a diaper, a pull up, or regular underwear.
Instead of going through tons of pull ups, place these over underwear during potty training when you’re fairly confident your child won’t be having a major accident. Small leaks and minor accidents will be caught by the waterproof plastic.
Not only will this expedite the potty training process, but it’ll save you a lot of money since you can reuse these after a simple washing.
We really like that the waistband and leg openings are made of a soft spandex. Many plastic covers can be really uncomfortable, but the spandex ensures your child can move around with ease without getting scratched or irritated.
If you don’t have a lot of money for pull ups and are willing to experiment with going straight to regular underwear, these are a great choice.
- Super affordable and can be reused over and over again.
- Comfortable spandex lining ensures your child’s comfort and prevents irritation.
- Protects against minor leaks and accidents.
- Not a good choice for protecting against major accidents and blowouts or for use at night.
The Low Down on Pull Ups
With a lot of patience, a little bit of excitement, and the best pull up diaper, you and your child can have a positive potty training experience.
We’d love to hear your thoughts on using pull ups and what has worked or not worked for you. And, if you know some other moms going through this phase of life, make sure to share this with them too.