Hearing your baby cry from teething pain is heartbreaking. You just want to take the pain away, but finding the right relief can feel overwhelming. You need a toy that is safe, effective, and easy for tiny hands to hold.
Some teethers are too hard, while others have nooks and crannies that trap mold. You also need to be sure the materials are free from nasty chemicals like BPA.
We tested top-rated brands to find the best teething toys available. These picks are safe, durable, and parent-approved to help soothe those sore gums.
- Dishwasher safe
- Babies can hold them easily
- Non-toxic, phthalate-free, BPA-free
- Inexpensive
- Made entirely of soft, chewy silicone
- Comes with a case
- Multifarious textures
- Passed all safety testing certification
- Massages baby’s gums
- Smooth, round edges
- Heavy-duty teether
- Perfect for baby's grip
- FDA approved
- Affordable and non-toxic
- Freezer and dishwasher safe
- Award-winning grasping toy
- Non-toxic & water based
- Attractive bright colors
- Keeps baby entertained
- Wide variety of shapes to choose
- Comes with 9 toys
When Should I Give My Baby Teething Toys?
Most babies cut their first tooth between 4 and 6 months old (1). However, teething pain often starts weeks before you see that little white pearl pop through.
Pro Tip
How to Choose Teething Toys for Baby
The market is flooded with cute toys, but you need to look past the aesthetics. Here are the specific factors to consider to ensure you get a safe and useful product.
Material
Many parents worry about plastics and the potential for chemical ingestion. If you want to avoid plastic entirely, look for teethers made from natural wood, organic cotton, or food-grade silicone. Silicone is particularly popular because it is soft, durable, and easy to sanitize.
Fillings
Some teethers are filled with water or gel. You can pop these in the fridge to get them cold, which numbs sore gums. However, these come with a risk. If your baby has sharp new teeth, they could puncture the casing and ingest the fluid. If you choose this type, inspect it for leaks every single time.
Clips
Let’s face it, babies drop everything. A teether that falls on the floor at the grocery store is useless until you can wash it. Look for toys that come with a pacifier clip, or have a loop where you can attach one. This keeps the toy within reach and off the dirty ground.
Easy-grip
Your baby is still developing fine motor skills. If a toy is too heavy or wide, they will get frustrated and drop it. Look for designs with open loops, handlebars, or distinct rings. Textured handles also help them keep a firm grip when the toy inevitably gets covered in drool.
Noisiness
Some teethers squeak or rattle when chewed. While babies often love the cause-and-effect stimulation, it might drive you crazy. If you prefer a quiet home, or if you plan to use the teether during church or quiet time, opt for a silent silicone or wooden toy.
Size
Safety is your top priority. Babies put everything in their mouths, presenting a choking risk. A safe teething toy must be too large to swallow. A simple test is to see if the toy fits inside a toilet paper roll. If it fits entirely inside, it is a choking hazard.
Product Reviews
We evaluated durability, safety materials, ease of cleaning, and texture variety to find the best options for your little one.
Bonbino Teether Rings 4-Pack
Best Teething Rings
If you prefer a classic design without bells and whistles, this four-pack is a solid choice. These silicone rings are non-toxic, phthalate-free, and BPA-free.
The standout feature here is the texture variety. Each ring has different ridges and bumps, letting your baby find the exact sensation that soothes their specific pain. The ring shape is incredibly easy for small hands to grasp and manipulate.
Plus, the design is versatile. You can wear them on your wrist like a bracelet, ensuring you always have a clean teether ready when a meltdown strikes.
Pros
- Easy to clean: They are dishwasher safe for quick sanitizing.
- Ergonomic: The ring shape is perfect for developing grip strength.
- Bonus content: Includes an e-book with extra teething tips.
Cons
- Size limitations: The rings might be too large to reach the back molars comfortably.
- Value: Some parents feel the price is high for simple silicone rings.
Our Ratings
Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teething Toy
Best Silicone Teething Toy
This Nuby teether is crafted from 100 percent soft silicone, making it flexible and durable. One end features soft bristles that massage sore gums, acting almost like a pre-toothbrush to get them used to oral care.
It includes a hygienic carrying case, which is a game-changer for travel. You can toss it in your diaper bag without worrying about lint or crumbs sticking to the silicone.
Pros
- Budget-friendly: It is an affordable option for most families.
- Grip-friendly: The attached ring makes it easy for babies to hold independently.
- Sanitary: The included travel case keeps it clean on the go.
Cons
- Magnet for hair: If you have pets, fur tends to stick to this material easily.
- Size: It can be slightly bulky for very small mouths (under 3 months).
Our Ratings
Baby Elefun Teethers Teething Toy
Best for Early Teethers (3-4 Months Old)
This elephant-shaped toy is designed to catch your baby’s eye with bright colors while offering relief. It is lightweight and has multiple grasp points, making it ideal for younger babies (around 3 to 4 months) who are just learning to hold objects.
The design incorporates five different textures. This variety keeps babies interested and helps stimulate their sensory development while they chew.
Pros
- Texture variety: Keeps your child engaged with different sensations.
- Certified safe: Passes rigorous safety testing standards.
- Gum massage: Raised bumps provide a gentle massage effect.
Cons
- Durability: Heavy chewers might show wear and tear faster than with solid rings.
- Design complexity: The intricate shape can be slightly harder to hand wash thoroughly.
Our Ratings
Sili Chews Cell Phone Toddler Teething Toy
Best Teething Toy for Toddlers
Toddlers always want what they can’t have, especially your smartphone. This teether mimics a phone, giving them their own “tech” to chew on. It is a clever distraction that might save your actual device from drool damage.
The silicone is food-grade and free from paints, so you don’t have to worry about chipping. It is also incredibly easy to clean; a quick rinse or a run through the dishwasher does the trick.
Pros
- Easy to hold: The size mimics a real phone but fits toddler hands.
- Textured surface: Ridges and buttons provide satisfying chew points.
- Distraction tool: Ideally keeps your toddler away from your real electronics.
Cons
- Price point: It is more expensive than standard teething rings.
- Novelty wears off: Smart toddlers may eventually realize it doesn’t light up or play videos.
Our Ratings
Lamaze Freddie the Firefly Teething Toy
Best Teething Toy Animals
Freddie the Firefly is more than just a teether; it is a full sensory activity toy. It combines soft plush sections for cuddling with dedicated chewing wings to soothe gums.
It features a “peek-a-boo” mirror, crinkly wings, and clacking rings to keep your baby entertained in the stroller or car seat. The attached clip makes it easy to secure to a travel system, preventing it from hitting the floor.
Pros
- Multipurpose: Acts as a plush friend and a teething aid.
- Sensory development: Offers crinkles, clacks, and mirrors for stimulation.
- High contrast: Bright colors and patterns support visual development.
Cons
- Size: It runs a bit small compared to other plush activity toys.
- Cleaning: Because it is plush, it takes longer to dry than silicone toys.
Our Ratings
Tinabless 5-Pack Teething Toys
Best Freezable Teething Toy
Cold is a natural anesthetic for gum pain. These fruit-shaped teethers are designed to hold a chill without becoming rock-hard like water-filled teethers might.
The set includes different fruit shapes, like grapes and oranges, each offering a unique texture profile. The stems act as handles, featuring a no-slip grip that helps babies hold on even when their hands are wet. Since you get a pack of five, you can rotate them: keep some in the freezer and some in play.
Pros
- Sensory variety: Different fruits provide different chewing surfaces.
- Value: Getting five toys in one pack is excellent for the price.
- Versatile: Safe for the freezer and the dishwasher.
Cons
- Handle thickness: The stems are thin, which can be tricky for the youngest babies to control.
Our Ratings
Organic Farm Buddies Teething Rattle
Best Natural Teething Toy (Organic)
For the eco-conscious family, this rattle is a winner. It is made from 100 percent organic cotton and filled with sustainable, hypoallergenic corn fiber.
Unlike plastic toys, this offers a soft, fabric texture that some babies prefer for gnawing. It doubles as a comfort object, bridging the gap between a security blanket and a teether. The rattle sound is gentle, not jarring.
Pros
- Eco-friendly: Made with natural, organic materials.
- Design options: Available in cute characters like a fox, cow, or boxer dog.
- Softness: Perfect for babies who want something squishy to chew on.
Cons
- Quiet rattle: The sound is very subtle, which might not engage some babies.
- Grip: The wide handle can be tough for small hands to encircle.
- Maintenance: Fabric shows wear and stains faster than silicone or wood.
Our Ratings
Manhattan Toy Wooden Beads Teether
Best Wooden Teething Toy
This classic toy features large wooden beads connected by a durable elastic cord. The finish is smooth and non-toxic, ensuring no splinters or chemical leaching.
It acts as a fantastic manipulative toy. Babies can twist, pull, and distort the shape, which rewards them with a satisfying wooden “clack” sound. It is substantial and durable, often lasting through multiple children.
Pros
- Safety first: The beads are large enough to prevent choking hazards.
- Motor skills: Encourages two-handed play and twisting motions.
- Aesthetics: The bright, water-based colors look great in the nursery.
Cons
- Weight: It is heavier than plastic, which might surprise younger babies.
- Impact: If a baby swings it too hard, the heavy wood can hurt if it hits their face.
Our Ratings
Nuby IcyBite Keys Teething Toy
Best Nuby Teething Toy
These iconic keys are a staple in many households. The “keys” contain a non-toxic purICE gel that stays cool longer than water-filled teethers. This cold therapy helps reduce inflammation in swollen gums.
The top of the keys is made of harder plastic, while the bottom is soft and cool. This dual-texture design allows your baby to choose the hardness they need at that moment. The easy-grip ring is sized perfectly for little hands.
Pros
- Cooling effect: The gel holds a chill effectively to numb pain.
- Cost-effective: Affordable enough to buy multiples.
- Texture mix: Combines hard and soft surfaces for different stages of teething.
Cons
- Leak risk: Like all gel toys, it can be punctured by sharp new teeth.
- Cleaning: The crevices between the keys and the ring can be tricky to scrub.
Our Ratings
WishTime Rattle Teething Toy Set
Best Teething Toy Set
If you aren’t sure what your baby will like, this variety pack covers all bases. It includes nine different rattles and teethers, ensuring your baby won’t get bored.
The toys are made from BPA-free ABS plastic and silicone. A huge plus is the included baby bottle-shaped storage case. It keeps the toys organized and clean, and eventually, the container itself becomes a fun toy for toddlers to fill and dump.
Pros
- Entertainment: Many of the toys rattle or make noise.
- Variety: Offers a wide range of shapes and handles.
- Portable: The storage case makes it easy to take the whole set to grandma’s house.
Cons
- Finish: Some edges may feel slightly rougher than premium brands.
- Volume: The horn toy in the set can be surprisingly loud.
Teething Toy FAQs
Can Teething Toys Damage Teeth?
When used correctly, teething toys will not damage incoming teeth. You must choose toys specifically designed for teething that are free from small parts. However, always inspect the toy for damage. If a baby chews on a broken or sharp edge, that could cause injury.
How Many Teething Toys Do Babies Need?
Every baby is different, but having a rotation of 3 to 5 toys is ideal. This ensures you always have a clean one available if one drops on the floor. It also lets you offer different textures (wood, silicone, cooling gel) to see what soothes your baby best.
Do You Freeze or Refrigerate Teething Toys?
You should generally stick to the refrigerator. Freezing can make teething rings rock-hard, which might bruise your baby’s delicate gums or hurt their lips. Always check the manufacturer’s instructions, as some silicone toys are freezer-safe, but water-filled ones are usually fridge-only.
Is the Gel Inside Teething Rings Toxic?
Reputable brands use non-toxic, water-based gels or purified water. However, you should still avoid leaks. If you see a puncture or fluid leaking out, throw the toy away immediately. It is better to be safe than sorry.
When Should You Remove Teething Toys?
Retire a teething toy immediately if you see cracks, tears, or loose parts. Also, keep an eye on the size; as your baby grows, smaller teethers might become choking hazards. Most children naturally lose interest in these toys once their primary teeth have emerged.
What Are the Safest Teething Toys for Babies?
The safest options are molded from a single piece of material (like silicone or wood) so nothing can break off. Look for BPA-free and phthalate-free labels. Brands like Nuby and Manhattan Toy are well-regarded for safety.
How Do I Clean Teething Toys?
For solid silicone or plastic toys, warm soapy water or the top rack of the dishwasher usually works best. For wooden or electronic teethers, wipe them down with a damp cloth and mild soap; do not submerge them. Always let them air dry completely to prevent mold growth.
The Bottom Line
The Bonbino 4-pack of teether rings takes our top spot. Sometimes simple is best. We love that they are incredibly easy to clean, simple for babies to grip, and offer enough texture to scratch that itch on the gums.
Because they are solid silicone, you don’t have to worry about funky gels leaking out. Plus, having four in a pack means you can keep one in the nursery, one in the car, and one in the diaper bag, so relief is always within reach.
