If you’re worried about modesty while breastfeeding in public, your best bet is getting a modest nursing cover that will keep your privates, well, private.
Two popular options are the Milk Snob and Covered Goods, as both provide great all-around coverage. If you’re trying to decide between these two covers, you’ve come to the right place.
We’ve used them extensively and have spent hours reading reviews from other moms who’ve used them. We’ll outline the differences between the Milk Snob vs. the Covered Goods nursing covers, highlighting their features and laying out their pros and cons, so you can decide which cover will suit you best.
Side By Side Comparison
As you will notice from the following comparison table, these two products are almost identical in their specifications.
|Milk Snob||Covered Goods|
|Price||Check Price||Check Price|
|Weight||6.4 ounces||6.4 ounces|
|Dimensions||0.8 x 6.5 x 7.5 inches||9 x 7 x .5 inches|
|Material||Rayon blend||Rayon blend|
|Color Options||8 on Amazon (30 on Website)||7|
|Size||Fits most||Fits most|
|Made In||The U.S.||The U.S.|
The Milk Snob Review
This is a multi-purpose nursing cover that you can use as a car seat cover, shopping cart cover, a blanket, or a highchair cover.
When you use it for breastfeeding, you can be comfortable that nothing will show unless you want it to.
The product has become a household name with breastfeeding mothers since appearing on the reality show SharkTank and receiving a $150,000 offer from Lori Greiner.
Pros & Cons
- It’s cute and stylish.
- It’s versatile.
- The four-way stretch helps it fit on a variety of car seats.
- It’s pretty hot to use for summer.
- Not a great choice for pumping.
- You should hand wash it, not machine wash.
Let’s look at some of the key benefits of using The Milk Snob.
Ease of Use
This stretchy nursing cover is easy to use whether you’re using it for breastfeeding in public or you’re trying to put it on a shopping cart to protect your baby from germs.
Since it offers a four-way stretch, it’s easy to fit onto the products you’re trying to cover it with — like car seats and high chairs.
It’s hard to make a quality nursing cover that serves so many purposes, but the Milk Snob seems to do the trick. The four-way stretch fabric lets it retain its shape and makes it easy enough to stretch over objects of different sizes.
The Milk Snob is so big that it even stretches over big shopping carts, not just the smaller ones. But you should be aware that once you stretch it out really big, it can lose some of its ability to snap back.
This nursing cover doesn’t come with a pouch to store it in while it isn’t in use, which would help if you want to stick it in your diaper bag for when you need it instead of wearing it all day.
Milk Snob recommends the cover be hand-washed, which isn’t the best for busy moms who would rather toss it in the washing machine.
What Makes The Milk Snob Better Than Covered Goods?
Both the Milk Snob and Covered Goods nursing covers are very similar. No matter which one you go with, they’ll be stretchy and soft.
- It’s a tighter fit: If you’re after a snugger breastfeeding experience, or if you generally shop at stores where the carts are a little smaller, you might want to go with the Milk Snob. It’s not as wide, and it’s shorter than the Covered Goods nursing cover.
- It’s better for petite women: If you’re a shorter, smaller woman and you’re worried a bigger nursing cover will swallow you up, keep in mind Covered Goods is several inches longer than the Milk Snob. You might feel more comfortable wearing the Milk Snob.
- It’s a better scarf: While you aren’t buying a maternity cover solely to use as a scarf, if you do want to wear it instead of sticking it in your diaper bag, the Milk Snob fits better as a scarf than the Covered Goods cover. Because it isn’t as wide or as long, it’s more comfortable than the Covered Goods cover.
Covered Goods Review
amazon box=”B01MTVTNHR” template=”product-image” value=”thumb” image_size=”large” tpl_size=large” tpl_float=”center” tpl_link=”no” tracking_id=”mlb-mlb-nursing-covers-20″]
Covered Goods has four uses — it can be a nursing cover, car seat cover, infinity scarf, or shopping cart cover.
Not only will it help keep your breasts hidden while breastfeeding, but it can also protect your baby from germs, the sun, and wind.
It’s made from 5% spandex which gives it that extra stretch and versatility.
Pros & Cons
- Longer than some other nursing covers.
- Super soft material.
- Wider than some other nursing covers.
- It’s easy to clean — you can put it in the washing machine.
- It might be too long for petite women.
- It can be a bit wide to use as a scarf.
Let’s look at what the Covered Goods nursing cover can offer moms.
Ease of Use
Covered Goods is easy to use, but some of its uses are simpler than others.
As a nursing cover, it’s pretty straightforward. But as a shopping cart cover, it’s a little more difficult to use. It can be hard to drape properly onto the cart until you get the hang of it.
As a scarf, you’ll have to keep winding it around and around, so it circles your neck several times. Otherwise, it will want to slip off to one side or over your shoulder.
The Covered Goods cover is well designed as a nursing cover. It’s long enough that women won’t have to worry about showing off their lower back while breastfeeding.
Plus, it’s wider than many other nursing covers, which means it’s a good choice for bigger women.
The biggest downside to the build quality of the Covered Goods nursing cover is that it loses some of its ability to spring back into shape if you stretch it out too much.
Although this doesn’t come with a carrying bag, it will stay fresh and clean when you aren’t wearing it, and the Covered Goods nursing cover is easy to clean. It can go in your washing machine on the cold setting.
And when you are done washing it, you can even put it in the dryer on low heat. That makes things a lot easier for busy moms who are too tired or frazzled to add hand washing an item to their to-do list.
What Makes Covered Goods Better Than the Milk Snob?
The Covered Goods cover offers some benefits the Milk Snob doesn’t.
- It’s wider: Covered Goods is a little wider, making it a better choice for plus-size moms.
- It’s longer: This nursing cover is several inches longer than the Milk Snob cover. That means you’ll be able to cover up your lower back and backside a little more when you’re breastfeeding. That can be a big perk for moms worried about modesty or wearing lower-rise pants as their C-section incision is healing.
- It’s better for bigger shopping carts: If grocery shopping for you means loading up as much stuff in oversized carts as you can, then the Covered Goods cover would be a good choice. Because it’s wider and longer, it can adequately cover up even really large shopping carts.
Which Is Right For You?
Because these nursing covers are both multi-purpose and so similar, it can be difficult to choose between them. No matter which one you choose, it will be soft and stretchy.
The Milk Snob cover might be a better fit if you’re a petite mom because it’s narrower and shorter. When you wear it or use it as a scarf, you won’t feel like you’re being swallowed up by the cover.
If you’re a plus-sized mom or a tall mom, you may want to go with the Covered Goods cover because of the extra width and length it offers.